@TwinsPrez, Why Don’t You Want Me To Be a Twins Fan?

I really don’t get it.

I’ve been a Twins fan since the summer I turned five years old. 1961. The year the Twins played their first season in Minnesota.

Even as a teenager, after my family moved to Iowa and the Twins entered one of their “dark periods” in the mid 1970s, I remained true.

It hasn’t always been easy. Through most of my life, there really wasn’t any way to watch the Twins down here on television, or even listen to them on the radio. There just wasn’t enough interest, I guess. It was easy to be a Cubs fan. Or a Braves fan, for that matter.

You see a few Twins caps around Cedar Rapids and the surrounding area, so it would appear that the Twins have been making inroads in the area. But that appearance is flat out wrong.

In fact, the opposite is true. The Twins obviously are not the least bit interested in developing a fan base in the Waterloo-Cedar Rapids-Iowa City corridor. Actually, it’s not that they aren’t interested.

It’s worse than that.

They DON’T WANT us to be Twins fans down here. They go out of their way to discourage us from being Twins fans. They encourage us to bring up our kids to be Cubs fans… or Cardinal fans… or… wait for it… yes, even White Sox fans!

You see… we can’t watch Twins games here. FSN isn’t carried by the cable systems here. I don’t believe it ever has been. I’ve seen no indication that there’s ever been any interest expressed by FSN in being carried by any of the cable systems here. There’s already plenty of baseball… Cubs baseball… some Cardinals baseball… and White Sox baseball carried on Mediacom here.

So when MLB introduced their MLB.tv package a few years ago… allowing fans to watch games on the internet… I was thrilled. Then I found out all of Iowa was blacked out of Twins games… and Cubs games… and White Sox games… and Cardinals games… and Brewers games… and Royals games. Yep. The entire state of Iowa was claimed as a “local broadcast area” for SIX teams, despite no MLB teams being located in the state.

Look, I understand that the broadcast rights of media partners have to be protected. But when those broadcasters have never, do not now, and clearly never will be carried by any of the major cable systems in an area, just exactly what “rights” are being protected? It’s insane.

It’s also an issue that’s been brought to MLB’s (and their member teams) attention repeatedly.

Check this out… from no less authority than baseball’s own MLB.com:

Baseball’s current rules on territorial television blackouts were drawn up in the 1960s, long before the dawn of MLB.TV and the Extra Innings package.

Those rules have become archaic, and Bob DuPuy, MLB’s president and chief operating officer, presented a plan to MLB’s executive council on Wednesday that would alter them considerably…

So why am I complaining if such a high ranking MLB executive is on the case? Well, that “promise” comes from an article written back in August… of 2008. DuPuy’s proposal was tabled at the subsequent owners meeting… apparently on a very long table.

Every season, there are articles written about the blackout rules. Those articles generally have several things in common. (a) the author is amazed at the stupidity of the rules, (b) someone “official” explains the rules go back to the 1960s and agree they are arcane and should be changed, and (c) nothing changes.

Every. Single. Year.

Dave St. Peter (@TwinsPrez)

The last straw, for me, came after I returned from spending a full week down in Ft. Myers watching the Twins practice and play meaningless games… something I’ve done for several years. A couple of days after returning home, I noticed the following exchange with Twins President Dave St. Peter on Twitter:

TwinsPrez Dave St. Peter
I support need to protect local rightsholder. Hope to offer in-market streaming soonRT @jeffgabhart:What’s your stance on MLB.tv blackouts?

Yeah… I couldn’t resist responding to that.

The “protect local rightsholder” argument is exactly what baseball has been regurgitating as an excuse for NOT offering in-market streaming for years. So what exactly was Mr. St. Peter saying?

I give him credit for being willing to participate in a direct and open social media exchange with the masses. I thought I would give him an opportunity to publicly clarify his statement:

@TwinsPrez so you see nothing wrong with all of Iowa blacked out of games for SIX teams?

He didn’t respond publicly, unfortunately, but he did send a private message via Twitter.

TwinsPrez— Not at all. I’d love to see this policy changed.

Now… with all due respect… Mr. St. Peter, you’re the President of the Minnesota Twins! It’s all very nice that you’d “love to see this policy changed,” but that doesn’t do me and the rest of the Twins (and Royals and Brewers and Cardinals and White Sox and Cubs) fans a damn bit of good.

The Twins have established all of Iowa as part of their “local broadcast market” despite not bothering to insist that those “rightsholders” actually… you know… do something about getting their networks available in this market. I’m tired of hearing bigwigs like St. Peter, and like DuPuy before him, tell me they’d like to see the policy change.

Stop blowing smoke up my ass and change the damn policy! Just f’ing DO IT!

If this is coming off to some of you as being a bit disrespectful and even crude, I apologize. But you see, I’ve tried other approaches. I wrote a very respectful letter to Commissioner Bud Selig (and if you’ve read some of the stuff I’ve written here reflecting my opinion of Mr. Selig, you know how difficult it was to be respectful… but I was). I’m still waiting for an answer… even just an acknowledgement. I suppose I may still get one, but I wrote that letter the same year of the MLB.com article, 2008. Pardon me if I don’t hold my breath continuing to wait for a result to my respectful approach.

I agreed to be interviewed for a story on the subject by a respected financial magazine. I expressed frustration, but in a respectful manner.

I’ll go back to being respectful when there’s some indication from someone in charge that changes are actually being made. Until then, I will continue to rant with increasing levels of disrespect, if that’s how I’m feeling (and I think you can safely assume I’ll feel that way every. single. game. that I can’t watch the Twins play due to the blackout rules).

After all, the Twins and MLB executives must earn respect, just like anyone else. I will go back to showing them respect when they begin showing me some respect. When you flat out lie, year after year, about “doing something” about the blackout rules, you’re not treating me with much respect… and you will get little from me, in return.

Mr. St. Peter… if you really would like to see this policy changed… if you were being honest about hoping to see “in market streaming soon”… please do more than talk (or tweet) about it. For the first time… ever… on this subject. Do something about it.


I can’t begin to express how frustrated I am over this. But I will say this, right now.

I will not remain a Twins fan if this idiocy continues. This will be my final year.

If this policy is not changed, I will not be going to Ft. Myers next spring.

I will certainly not make trips to the Twin Cities to watch close to 20% of the Twins’ home games like I did last season… in fact I won’t drive up there to attend any games.

I will not continue my work on this or any other Twins blog.

I know the Twins won’t miss me. They don’t need to develop or nurture a fan base all the way down in Eastern Iowa when their new stadium is sold out every game anyway. But what happens when the newness wears off… when the team has to rebuild a bit?

Mr. St. Peter, when you look around for fans willing to continue supporting the team in the leaner years, don’t look in my direction. In fact, don’t look down here in Iowa for anyone else, either… we’ll all be fans of some organization that gives a crap about us. (My son is already an Orioles fan… think about that for a moment, Mr. St. Peter. He and his wife are about to start a family… do you want my grandkids to be at all interested in the Twins… or not?)

I simply won’t continue to show any level of devotion to an organization that not only doesn’t care if I remain a fan, but seems to go out of their way to communicate to me and my friends and family that they flat out don’t want us to watch their games.

I love the Twins. I love the Twins community. I love this group of players. So I may make it through this season with my Twins fandom intact.

Then again, I may not.

– JC

11 thoughts on “@TwinsPrez, Why Don’t You Want Me To Be a Twins Fan?

  1. I live just north of the Cities and I have to agree that Iowa is just flat out screwed by these blackout rules (I find blackouts in general to be pointless anyway because of the “if the game isn’t sold out, you can’t watch it” for Vikings football, but that’s likely never going to change). FanGraphs has already done a post or two during the offseason about the very same thing.


    For those that don’t like clicking on links, the first one is just a vote to see how much people would be willing to pay to have blackout free MLB.tv. The main votes were between $0-$60 but amazingly, nearly 17% of voters would be willing to pay $100 or more.

    The second link is from Dave Cameron – who lives in North Carolina and is blacked out from 4 teams – ranting about the blackout policy, much like you did, JC. Funny thing is that Dave’s favorite team is the Mariners, but he’s a big enough fan that he’d like to watch the Orioles, Nationals, Braves, and Reds as well, but is blacked out from all of those.

    I don’t really have much more to add… I mean, I can’t say much without starting to repeat what you and Dave have already said. Maybe if someone told them how much money they could make if this was fixed, they’d actually care a little more.

  2. Have you tried using a proxy server or UltraSurf? A pain and not so much playing by the rules, but clearly the rules are stupid and should be ignored.

  3. I’ll offer a brief note of hope. I spent the first two years of an mlb.tv subscription not being able to watch any games in Japan! Given that there might be only 1 game per day on NHK, if we’re lucky, that didn’t make much sense. I used to mark the games v Mariners (Ichiro) or Yankees (Matsui) in hopes they were the days broadcast. The good news (I hope) for you, is somehow that policy changed!

    Good luck with your battle. Is there anything we (your followers) can collectively do to help.

  4. Great post. This stuff drives me crazy, especially when consumers are cutting luxury items (like satellite and big cable packages) and moving more and more of their viewing hours to online sources (i.e. Netflix & Hulu). I had no idea that the “blackout rules” come from the 1960s…absurd.

    If MLB wanted to make the most of their summer in the sun (while the NFL/NBA eat themselves up with labor strife) they’d come out as the most pro-fan league of them all. Keep offering out of market fans the MLB.Tv package, and offer in-market fans streaming (with commercials) for a little less than standard cable–bypassing the middleman and getting straight to their customers. Advertisers get more revenue, channels get more revenue, teams get more revenue, fans get a better product and ultimately save some money that they can spend on more baseball stuff!

    Keep the faith…and keep fighting the good fight.

  5. I wonder if there is some legal action that could be taken. How can the Twins/MLB claim a ‘home market’ for their team for a city that is 500 miles away.
    The blackouts make no sense too. Look at northern Minnesota. A swath of area is Twins/Brewers land, but the arrowhead is solidly Twins. So you live in Duluth, you are in disputed territory, but move to Grand Marais you get to watch Twins game…IT MAKES NO SENSE

  6. I wonder if the black out area is written into the existing contract with FSN. If so, I think that ends after 2011 or 2012.

  7. I live in Waterloo Iowa and was also frustrated about the blackout policy on MLB.com. But I contacted Dish Network and for a small premium I was able to choose FSN-North as my preferred sports network and now get 150 Twins games a year. It is well worth it. Got rid of cable Also the Twins did sign up AM1250 in our market. Although it is a very weak signal and gets hard to recieve at night.

  8. Pingback: Join The JimCrikket Anti-MLB Blackout Movement » Knuckleballs - "Like butterflies with hiccups"

  9. Thank you all for your support… see my follow up post on the subject if you’d like to demonstrate your support via social media.

    E, I’ve tried the proxy server route without any luck… maybe I’m just doing something wrong. Frankly, I’m past the point of caring about playing by MLB’s rules. The rules are asinine. If I can figure out a way to get the games using a proxy server, I’ll do it in a heartbeat.

    Rick, for a variety of reasons, DirectTV isn’t an option for me, nor for a significant segment of people who can’t do satellite due to financial reasons or because dishes aren’t an option due apartment/condo/neighborhood restrictions. And frankly, given the problems my friends with dishes have any time there’s a raindrop between their dish and the satellite it’s aimed at, I’m not sure I’d want to go that route anyway… and I shouldn’t have to.

  10. Pingback: Flipping The @MinnesotaTwins The Bird » Knuckleballs - "Like butterflies with hiccups"

  11. Pingback: Call It The Knuckleballs Playoff Plan » Knuckleballs - "Like butterflies with hiccups"